| Platinum | Paige's Bakehouse |
| Gold | Papi's Pies |
| Silver | Cookies and Crumbles Bake Shop |
| Bronze | Jada's Sweets |
| Top Pick | Fantasy Cakes |
| Top Pick | Humble Pie Desserts |
| Top Pick | Kayla Knight Cakes |
| Top Pick | Paiges Bake House |
| Top Pick | Pie Jacked |
| Top Pick | Sweet Tooth Parlor |